Ultimately I like it! It's sturdy and stylish and matches the leather leash I bought from the same company.It was a bit larger than I expected, I supposed because I had a generic silicone dispenser in mind (see picture) and I assumed it was that size. Also based on so many reviews saying they couldn't get the bags to fit - but I have no idea what they are talking about, the standard bag roll fit in the slot just fine. In fact I do think the whole thing is a little bit too big, even a full bag roll just sort of rattles around in there, it's never held tight in place. But still, it fit in just fine. I was a little worries that when the roll got down to the last few bags it might fall out but that didn't happen.The sizing listed might be a little confusing too, the length is listed as 6 inches so I was confused from the beginning on what to expect but as you can see from the pictures the 6 inches would be if you measure from the bottom all the way up past the loop to the top of the extended clasp. The real length of the pouch itself is 3.5 inches. And in the picture I have it compared to the basic silicone pouch and a standard roll so you can see how huge it actually is. But in the end I still like it better than any other poop bag dispenser I've had and the high quality of the leather will only get better with age, like many of their other products so I'm still giving it 5 stars.